书籍 Why I Am Not a Buddhist的封面

Why I Am Not a Buddhist

Evan Thompson

出版时间

2020-01-28

ISBN

9780300226553

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Buddhism has become a uniquely favored religion in our modern age. A burgeoning number of books extol the scientifically proven benefits of meditation and mindfulness for everything ranging from business to romance. There are conferences, courses, and celebrities promoting the notion that Buddhism is spirituality for the rational; compatible with cutting-edge science; indeed, “a science of the mind.” In this provocative book, Evan Thompson argues that this representation of Buddhism is false.

In lucid and entertaining prose, Thompson dives deep into both Western and Buddhist philosophy to explain how the goals of science and religion are fundamentally different. Efforts to seek their unification are wrongheaded and promote mistaken ideas of both. He suggests cosmopolitanism instead, a worldview with deep roots in both Eastern and Western traditions. Smart, sympathetic, and intellectually ambitious, this book is a must-read for anyone interested in Buddhism’s place in our world today.

Evan Thompson is professor of philosophy at the University of British Columbia and a fellow of the Royal Society of Canada. He is the author of Waking, Dreaming, Being: Self and Consciousness in Neuroscience, Meditation, and Philosophy, among other books.

用户评论
主题是对魔改佛教(buddhist modernism)的开炮。我太喜欢第四章(对mindfulness科研的批判)和第五章(对enlightenment和liberation的定义)了,开了一摞书单回去。为什么我写毕业论文的时候这本书没出版呢嘤嘤嘤,用4E理论来理解注意力训练和禅修,这么骚的课题谁不想做啊!!!我导做梦都会笑醒(不会
对佛教现代主义的有力回应,逻辑清晰,论据充分,最后以世界主义作结,感觉只是个开端,毕竟我们对意识理解得太有限了。
对Buddhist Modernism批判一番。find it dull and repetitive when reading the philosophic arguments, but the debunking of evolutionary psychology (which constantly appears as a pseudo-scientific explanation of human behavior in media) and the 4E cognitive science are informative for a lay person and once "spiritual" Buddhist modernist like me :(
As a layman in both philosophy and buddhism, I find some chapters difficult. But I like how the author lays out his arguments in "Is buddhism true?" and "mindfulness mania". I myself have been considering some of the issues for some time, but could never think them through like the author does.
看到前两章,居然感到很兴奋~
提前读的reading 估计还得回头读几遍抠抠细节写essay 本书对于佛教哲学的很多中心问题进行了有见解的简单论述 考虑到作者的写作目标,这种写作风格是很恰当的,但对于没过多哲学文本积累的读着而言会产生阅读障碍。
似乎没有中译,是因为多次提到某和尚吧。对佛教现代主义(声称佛教是一种科学,抛弃其他佛教传统,独重冥想及冥想的个人体验)和 why buddhism is true 的严厉批评。
有对流行的正念、冥想的拨乱反正
分析几种正念那章有点意思,只是对佛教义理还有些停在文本