书籍 Anarchy, State and Utopia的封面

Anarchy, State and Utopia

Robert Nozick

出版时间

1977-10-21

ISBN

9780465097203

评分

★★★★★

标签

政治

书籍介绍

Robert Nozick's Anarchy, State, and Utopia is a powerful, philosophical challenge to the most widely held political and social positions of our age ---- liberal, socialist and conservative. "Individuals have rights," Nozick writes in his opening sentence, "and there are things no person or group may do to them without violating their rights." The work that follows is a sophisticated and passionate defence of the rights of the individual as opposed to the state. The author argues that the state is justified only when it is severely limited to the narrow function of protection against force, theft and fraud and to the enforcement of contracts. Any more extensive activities by the state, he demonstrates, will inevitably violate individual rights. Among the many achievements of the work are an important new theory of distributive justice, a model of utopia, and an integration of ethics, legal philosophy and economic theory into a profound position in political philosophy which will be discussed for years to come.

用户评论
天才之作…初读时特慢,倒不是难懂,而是努力想凭一己之力为罗尔斯辩护却最终哑口无言。只能慢慢借他人的引导走出Nozick的场域了。
話說某一年諾齊克on leave, 收拾行李的時候Dworkin 塞給了他一本羅爾斯花了十年撰寫的公平即正義。於是諾齊克在沙灘上曬太阳時讀著讀著說this is nonsense.然後他花了6個月寫出來liberitarianism 的hallmark.....於是多打一顆星
Nozick对Locke的批判不长,5页左右吧,字字珠玑呀,读得痛快淋漓的。不玩酸腐,极有逻辑。
恕我智商真的不够。。听得audible版本唯一听懂的只有第十章讲love那一小段。。。
在艰涩难懂和流畅明了之间徘徊。第一次读完整本,感觉整本书的行文相当跳跃,但这不妨碍诺齐克的一些观点和论述给人留下深刻印象。
文字真跳跃,看着脑壳疼 (给自己把看完这本这事儿一拖再拖找个借口)。 倒是不妨碍让人深刻的观点输出,minimal state又后设乌托邦的整个概念真迷人 哈哈哈哈
写得其实不坏,但感觉见地还是差Rawls一截。Libertarianism的论证太循环了,无论如何都要assume private property (rather than argue for it) 才成。牛津的两位,Brian Barry和Gerald Cohen,都有过对Nozick还算鞭辟入里的批评,都颇值得一读。
私有产权那块未见深入讨论