书籍 Hegel and Skepticism的封面

Hegel and Skepticism

Michael N. Forster

出版时间

1989-06-20

ISBN

9780674387072

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

The rejection by Anglo-Saxon philosophers of much "continental philosophy" (from Hegel on down) is largely based on the perceived failure of continental thinkers to grapple with the tough questions of epistemology in general and skepticism in particular. Forster demonstrates that Hegel did not in fact ignore epistemology, but on the contrary he fought a tireless and subtle campaign to defeat the threat of skepticism. Forster's work should dispel once and for all the view that Hegel was naive or careless in epistemological matters. Forster begins by discussing Hegel's critical interpretation of the skeptical tradition, in particular his convincingly argued case for the superiority of ancient over modern skepticism. He goes on to show that the difficulties characteristic of ancient skepticism play a crucial and fascinating role in Hegel's philosophy of history. Hegel sees in the emergence of these difficulties an explanation of why the harmonious unified Greek culture collapsed and was replaced by the division and alienation characteristic of subsequent western culture. Finally, Forster examines the elaborate and ingenious system of defenses erected by Hegel to protect his philosophical thought against skeptical difficulties, as the core of a somewhat broader epistemological project. Along the way, Forster makes much that has hither to remained obscure in Hegel's texts intelligible for the first time. This book should cause a re-evaluation of Hegel, and German Idealism generally, and contribute to a re-evaluation of the skeptical tradition in philosophy.

用户评论
从怀疑主义出发构建黑格尔的认识论确实是很有见地的思路,即有文本依据,又能把握“全体”。可惜的是这种把握还是很空洞乏味,跟“哲学无前提”一类格言没多大区别…反而是对青年黑格尔的研究有意思
完美定义了什么叫『典范之作』 而且无处不体现着fulda对他的影响 两位都是伟大的黑格尔学者
很好,比他那本关于康德的更清楚,清晰地阐明了黑格尔如何抵御怀疑论的攻击。当然实际上也回应了很多后黑格尔主义者,指出他们的攻击并不能真正触及到黑格尔,反而会给自己带来怀疑论的困扰。
都不記得是十二還是十三年前讀過了,居然才發現作者還是邁克爾·福斯特