书籍 Sold People的封面

Sold People

Johanna S. Ransmeier

出版时间

2017-03-19

ISBN

9780674971974

评分

★★★★★

标签

社会

书籍介绍

A robust trade in human lives thrived throughout North China during the late Qing and Republican periods. Whether to acquire servants, slaves, concubines, or children—or dispose of unwanted household members—families at all levels of society addressed various domestic needs by participating in this market. Sold People brings into focus the complicit dynamic of human trafficking, including the social and legal networks that sustained it. Johanna Ransmeier reveals the extent to which the structure of the Chinese family not only influenced but encouraged the buying and selling of men, women, and children.

For centuries, human trafficking had an ambiguous status in Chinese society. Prohibited in principle during the Qing period, it was nevertheless widely accepted as part of family life, despite the frequent involvement of criminals. In 1910, Qing reformers, hoping to usher China into the community of modern nations, officially abolished the trade. But police and other judicial officials found the new law extremely difficult to enforce. Industrialization, urbanization, and the development of modern transportation systems created a breeding ground for continued commerce in people. The Republican government that came to power after the 1911 revolution similarly struggled to root out the entrenched practice.

Ransmeier draws from untapped archival sources to recreate the lived experience of human trafficking in turn-of-the-century North China. Not always a measure of last resort reserved for times of extreme hardship, the sale of people was a commonplace transaction that built and restructured families as often as it broke them apart.

目录
Conventions
Introduction
1. A Young Woman as Portable Property
2. The Flow of Trafficking in the Late Qing
3. New Laws and Emerging Language

显示全部
用户评论
文笔超级好,就是8章读起来实在是辛苦。从买卖人口切入中国北方的家庭关系,全篇围绕transactional family而讨论,非常新颖,比起Sommer的卖老婆,视角更多元,但又有异曲同工的妙处。今年读过的里面很棒的一本~更加感谢导师课上的引导
对于我来说,其中关于家庭的部分更让人感兴趣。从微观的视角出发,家庭本身应该具有保护性的功能,以区别出社群的内外;然而家庭内部的等级又使得家庭变成了高位者的避险工具。联系起以前看过的一篇经济学文献(我想不起来名字了),换句话说,女性以及由女性生产出来的儿童都是作为避险工具存在;当风险来临的时候,政府没有力量帮助社会来抵御某些风险,这时候妇女儿童就变成了一种金融工具。这本书所叙述的故事,为这样的说法提供了鲜活的案例。因而,我所关注的是什么样的社会风险使得这种症结发生与存在?;其次,在一种更为现代性的家庭结构中,家庭以什么样的方式来度过这些风险?对于经济学家来说,现代社会丰富了金融产品的种类,弱化了女性作为金融工具使用的要素。可是,我还是想试图从结构出发来思考这个问题。
由买卖人口的社会史切入清末民初司法改革、王朝更替下的家庭结构变化。史料梳理很细致,叙事和分析融合得相当好,就是论点过于零散。作者想分析的核心矛盾之一是受国际废奴运动推动、基于人权主义的立法理想与传统观念和社会经济现实之间的冲突。法律漏洞、“妇女即财产”的观念(婚嫁礼金)和人贩子的“生存逻辑”(人口买卖在饥荒、战乱时期成为代替国家实现福利保障的手段)使人口买卖在一定程度上被默许。
参见书评 China Review International: Vol. 23, No. 2, 2016
在读ing。因为不好的人啃英文原著真的很悲伤,查词的时间远超看内容的时间。但能咋地,还不得看嘛。看完再说感想。
买卖人口的地理空间不仅限于华北,从河南到江西的水路,从北京到汉口的铁路,天津南门附近为代表的三不管地带,和上海租界的治外法权地带,都是人口贩卖制造和利用“距离”和“隔绝”的地方。
细节丰富文笔出众,分析部分也不拖后腿。先强调人口贩卖/流动的在中国的广泛接受程度和其社会经济逻辑,以此为出发点探讨普通家庭的生存策略、人贩子的行为逻辑、上层精英和国家对人口买卖的态度和民国时期司法系统的转变。关注宏观结构性变化和social mechanism的同时对discourse和process也有讨论。最后一章稍微失望,材料来源有些单一,还可以发掘更多。