书籍 The Code of Capital的封面

The Code of Capital

Katharina Pistor

出版时间

2019-05-28

ISBN

9780691178974

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

A compelling explanation of how the law shapes the distribution of wealth

Capital is the defining feature of modern economies, yet most people have no idea where it actually comes from. What is it, exactly, that transforms mere wealth into an asset that automatically creates more wealth? The Code of Capital explains how capital is created behind closed doors in the offices of private attorneys, and why this little-known fact is one of the biggest reasons for the widening wealth gap between the holders of capital and everybody else.

In this revealing book, Katharina Pistor argues that the law selectively “codesâ€� certain assets, endowing them with the capacity to protect and produce private wealth. With the right legal coding, any object, claim, or idea can be turned into capitalâ€"and lawyers are the keepers of the code. Pistor describes how they pick and choose among different legal systems and legal devices for the ones that best serve their clients’ needs, and how techniques that were first perfected centuries ago to code landholdings as capital are being used today to code stocks, bonds, ideas, and even expectationsâ€"assets that exist only in law.

A powerful new way of thinking about one of the most pernicious problems of our time, The Code of Capital explores the different ways that debt, complex financial products, and other assets are coded to give financial advantage to their holders. This provocative book paints a troubling portrait of the pervasive global nature of the code, the people who shape it, and the governments that enforce it.

Katharina Pistor is the Edwin B. Parker Professor of Comparative Law and director of the Center on Global Legal Transformation at Columbia Law School. She is the coauthor of Law and Capitalism: What Corporate Crises Reveal about Legal Systems and Economic Development around the World and the coeditor of Governing Access to Essential Resources. She lives in New York City.

用户评论
题目很好,切入点也具有吸引力,即作者开篇便提出自己与传统左派的区别在于关注律师在the codification of capital中的作用,而非assets holders。但为什么全书完全写成了一本极为浅显与泛泛而谈的教科书形式?大杂烩式的讨论历史,对社会事实的讨论未超出一般新闻媒体,最为重要的律师部分,也并没有做任何深入的调查与田野工作,而仅仅只是一种想象。越读越失望。
近乎读完,部分能容非常干燥,但也无法掩饰这本书的光彩。作者基本观点为:Capital is assets coded by law。资本的性质包括 - priority, convertibility, durability, universality。作者给出了大量实例以及历史来证明这些性质和观点,同时指出律师在资本世界的地位。每每读到一些和工作相关的实例,都超级兴奋且不禁想要膜拜!学习不止不止不止,还要努力努力努力!
作者一上来的private-public binary就决定整本书的scope其实很窄,其实就是想说law对private sphere的各种coding(i.e. 法律如何最大程度帮助富人钻法律的空子)有国家强有力的背书。后面lawyer那章很空洞,完全没解释这帮lawyer到底从哪来的,对common law, court, code的源头也缺乏解释,很多问题都高高举起轻轻放下。最费解的是为什么这种大佬能对Polanyi有这么大的误读,与经济学的对话还停留在单纯批判neoclassical的程度……
法律可以将财产标记为资本,从而使得原本仅可以供人持有/使用的有形或无形的财产变成可以产生财富的资本。作者提出了资本的新定义:资本=财产+法律,认为法律在创造财富和不均上有着重大的作用。可是法律并不是凭空而来的,作者认为律师在财产转化为资本的过程中起了极大的作用,有资源去聘请律师的人可以在很大程度上左右法律使得自己的钱不断生钱。这就又回到了鸡生蛋蛋生鸡的问题上来。总的来说还是一个比较新奇的角度吧
法律史部分有收获。问题也很明显,首先是车轱辘话来回说,想尽可能扩大读者群体并不足以为此提供正当性。其次,在如今定期发生金融危机的资本主义社会中,私人的优先权不一定是没有成本地取得的,这一点上,需要与圈地运动和殖民时期作出区分,作者以后者为例反对如今在法律层面对规则利用的创新,是比较牵强的。最后,作者的逻辑是:律师对资本的法律编码在利用法律漏洞、法律秩序之间的差异、非公开的仲裁为其客户牟利,这会导致本国法无法得到有效实施,而这些法律是民主社会的立法成果,因此,为了民主在资本主义社会占上风,必须对资本的法律编码进行限制。另一个辅助的论证是,即便蛋糕被做大了,也不一定能被社会分享。后一论点能否站得住值得怀疑,另外,民主社会的理想是怎样的,是一个为了公平对创新和竞争进行审查和遏制的社会吗?
主题很好...但是实在读不懂,遗憾有机会再读吧
听完立刻下单了实体书与《罗马私法》,与《封建社会》交叉验证了私权与财富如何被确立和编码。
以pistor的穿透力,总感觉这本书的论证还是浅了点。可能想处理的素材太多,也在避免过于学术性的论述?
非常好。深入浅出地讲解了律师如何在不同领域为资本创造它需要的法律,国家与资本如何相依相生,戳破了把蛋糕做大大家都有得吃的泡泡,也击碎了法律正义的面罩。难怪这么多欧美法律人感到被冒犯。
资本的变现少不了法律的参与,利用法律条款规定权限义务,从圈地运动到圈知识产权,从债务纠纷到破产逃脱。资本与法律是相辅相成的,未来的法律战场更多的是在于知识产权领域,从有型资产到无形资产。当然这部分是适用于西方资本主义社会,对于我们是有一定局限性的。我们的资本变现更多是来源于权利和不可说,结合费孝通等一些社科类研究不难发现,我们社会的变现和资本累积不是法律而人情,在法律的制定上依旧疏散,陈旧,以及loophole, 但由于金融监管政策的严格,和限制外资流入,真正的“资本”运作市场依旧在建设中。