书籍 Know Your Remedies的封面

Know Your Remedies

He Bian

出版时间

2020-03-31

ISBN

9780691179049

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Know Your Remedies presents a panoramic inquiry into China’s early modern cultural transformation through the lens of pharmacy. In the history of science and civilization in China, pharmacy—as a commercial enterprise and as a branch of classical medicine—resists easy characterization. While China’s long tradition of documenting the natural world through state-commissioned pharmacopeias, known as bencao, dwindled after the sixteenth century, the ubiquitous presence of Chinese pharmacy shops around the world today testifies to the vitality of Traditional Chinese Medicine. Rejecting narratives of intellectual stagnation or an unchanging folk culture, He Bian argues that pharmacy’s history in early modern China can best be understood as a dynamic interplay between elite and popular culture.

Beginning with decentralizing trends in book culture and fiscal policy in the sixteenth century, Bian reveals pharmacy’s central role in late Ming public discourse. Fueled by factional politics in the early 1600s, amateur investigation into pharmacology reached peak popularity among the literati on the eve of the Qing conquest in the mid-seventeenth century. The eighteenth century witnessed a systematic reclassification of knowledge, as the Qing court turned away from pharmacopeia in favor of a demedicalized natural history. Throughout this time, growth in long-distance trade enabled the rise of urban pharmacy shops, generating new knowledge about the natural world.

He Bian is assistant professor of history and East Asian studies at Princeton University.

目录
Acknowledgments xi
Introduction 1
Part 1
1 The Last Pharmacopeia 23
2 Converting Tribute 49

显示全部
用户评论
“The struggle for authority over the nature of drugs continues to shed light on the complex interplay among knowledge, power, and ethics in modern China; pharmacy remains a good vantage point from which to observe the perennial search for consensus over the political administration of human nature.”
冲着Chapter 5去的……Plum in the Golden Vase,你真是历史学家的好朋友。
作者把本草知识的发展放在理学的变化还有明清以来的政治、经济方面的变化下来理解。感觉想表达的东西很多,时段也很长,但是篇幅太有限,不少地方应该还有进一步阐发的余地。宋代以来知识权威的去中心化是个复杂而曲折的过程,书里面处理得并不够清晰。作者前面写北宋政府11世纪就没有能力对本草知识进行控制(且不论是不是有这个打算),后面又说弘治皇帝的死标志着宫廷医学与理学士大夫开始争抢知识权威。那么南宋到金元这期间的情况又如何呢?作者回应列文森对儒家amateurism的批评,认为理学士大夫玩票本草和明末政局相关,而并非“an unchanging feature of Chinese elite culture”, 但又说玩票对本草知识产生了重大影响,既然如此,用amateurism是否有必要?
越读越喜欢边和的研究,是我梦寐以求的,对于整个时代有整体连贯认知的作品。就觉得有点不划算,因为虽然从医疗的角度重新解读early modern China,但是得出来的结论其实是对既有结论的细微修正,而没有那么响亮、耀眼。可是做研究又不是搞革命,不是吗?
视野开阔,细节处见功力。最喜欢第六章,打开了很多思路。
读完竟然很感动。边老师的文字读起来很舒服,写一个人,用一条线再连贯到下一个人,分析错杂在叙述里,给人读小说般的体验。而且作者从字里行间察势观风的能力真的好强,从生-有-出-产的变化观察到人地关系的变化,洞见藏在细节里。整本书也是站在“在中国发现历史”的立场上写的(To know our remedies is to know ourselves.)近代之后的中国要如何认识自己,真是长路漫漫。
终于读完了,药之为物。本草药材、药品的知识体系构建、制作、服用、销售的权威掌握在谁手中?这是考察明清变革的一个窗口。
相当优质的著作。考证虽然细致,但不拘泥于细节描述。
细读了第二章,边和延展性的写作,给写无甚相关的朝贡的我也能带来启发