书籍 The Meritocracy Trap的封面

The Meritocracy Trap

Daniel Markovits

出版社

Penguin Press

出版时间

2019-09-10

ISBN

9780735221994

评分

★★★★★

标签

社会学

书籍介绍

A revolutionary new argument from eminent Yale Law professor Daniel Markovits attacking the false promise of meritocracy It is an axiom of American life that advantage should be earned through ability and effort. Even as the country divides itself at every turn, the meritocratic ideal - that social and economic rewards should follow achievement rather than breeding - reigns supreme. Both Democrats and Republicans insistently repeat meritocratic notions. Meritocracy cuts to the heart of who we are. It sustains the American dream. But what if, both up and down the social ladder, meritocracy is a sham? Today, meritocracy has become exactly what it was conceived to resist: a mechanism for the concentration and dynastic transmission of wealth and privilege across generations. Upward mobility has become a fantasy, and the embattled middle classes are now more likely to sink into the working poor than to rise into the professional elite. At the same time, meritocracy now ensnares even those who manage to claw their way to the top, requiring rich adults to work with crushing intensity, exploiting their expensive educations in order to extract a return. All this is not the result of deviations or retreats from meritocracy but rather stems directly from meritocracy's successes. This is the radical argument that Daniel Markovits prosecutes with rare force. Markovits is well placed to expose the sham of meritocracy. Having spent his life at elite universities, he knows from the inside the corrosive system we are trapped within. Markovits also knows that, if we understand that meritocratic inequality produces near-universal harm, we can cure it. When The Meritocracy Trap reveals the inner workings of the meritocratic machine, it also illuminates the first steps outward, towards a new world that might once again afford dignity and prosperity to the American people.

用户评论
阿姨送我的书,她女儿头脑聪慧但体弱多病她很忧心,给我讲一些怪事比某州某校某年掩盖了N个学生自杀。我感觉现在美国高中也这样吧中国教育大省的高中每年都挂几个的。我认识的叔叔当校长受不了不干了。下午抓起来翻了一遍..作者慷慨陈词,类似hypereducated/superelite的大词简直吓死本韭了。他的观察和论据都非常实在-workplace training以前是雇主提供如今成本转嫁给了员工。但我觉得整本书忽视了了一个大的矛盾,即生产力与生产关系的矛盾,人力不值钱,制造合格劳动力的养育成本太高,更不用说医生律师等。养孩假设按照每年20W成本,复利10%20年后总成本1145W;换做15%复利总成本就变成2048W了..啥样的工作能justify这种投入啊?那可不就形成了一个trap..
没有新的论据。政策建议看p.277上两句话写清楚的就行了。
哭了 精准的说出我对各种精英行业的抵触。It's a system that humiliates the middle class and grinds the elites—>我收回。老师的观点的确非常fierce但不得不说是一本非常repetitive的书。https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3RITVJy7ogI&list=PLZqlasNR4OUDwpKqADRT79lr7P_zt08MV看这个辩论足矣
The overconfident elite & a group of depressed ppl tried in vain to alleviate the inequality caused by the system. The continued embrace of financial products and debt-backed consumption for decades finally triggered the financial turmoil & the Great Recession. This conclusion is unbelievably stupid
对一个发现印象很深:金领为了维持地位而疯狂工作,积累了大量财富却无法享受生活,因此而感到不幸福;中产工作的时间减少收入也减少,有了大量的时间却难以提高社会阶层/经济收入,也不幸福。这个世界啊。
翻过
还有1/3个conclusion没看完,但way below expectation已定。去年夏天在making sense上听到作者教授和Sam Harris的对谈,当时还挺震惊的,因此“第一次”被正面攻击了自己曾经非常深信且支持的meritocracy(绩优制),想来也确实是被它所宣扬的观点洗脑成功。但本书最多只值三星,因为论证过于重复累赘。
跳读 观点很有冲击力 啰嗦重复 查翻痛苦
我的political economics论文主要参考书目