书籍 The Government Next Door的封面

The Government Next Door

Luigi Tomba

出版时间

2014-08-11

ISBN

9780801479359

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Chinese residential communities are places of intense governing and an arena of active political engagement between state and society. In The Government Next Door, Luigi Tomba investigates how the goals of a government consolidated in a distant authority materialize in citizens' everyday lives. Chinese neighborhoods reveal much about the changing nature of governing practices in the country. Government action is driven by the need to preserve social and political stability, but such priorities must adapt to the progressive privatization of urban residential space and an increasingly complex set of societal forces. Tomba’s vivid ethnographic accounts of neighborhood life and politics in Beijing, Shenyang, and Chengdu depict how such local "translation" of government priorities takes place.

Tomba reveals how different clusters of residential space are governed more or less intensely depending on the residents’ social status; how disgruntled communities with high unemployment are still managed with the pastoral strategies typical of the socialist tradition, while high-income neighbors are allowed greater autonomy in exchange for a greater concern for social order. Conflicts are contained by the gated structures of the neighborhoods to prevent systemic challenges to the government, and middle-class lifestyles have become exemplars of a new, responsible form of citizenship. At times of conflict and in daily interactions, the penetration of the state discourse about social stability becomes clear.

Luigi Tomba is a Senior Fellow at the Australian Centre on China in the World, Australian National University. He is the author of Paradoxes of Labour Reform: Chinese Labour Theory and Practice from Socialism to the Market and coeditor of The China Journal.

目录
Introduction: The Neighborhood Consensus
1. Social Clustering: Neighborhoods and the Governing of Social Distinction
2. Micro-Governing the Urban Crisis
3. Housing and Social Engineering
4. Contained Contention: Interests, Places, Community, and the State

显示全部
用户评论
target in 3-5 years
雖然還是在「治理術」的框架內,但提出了consensus這個有意義的觀點,其實是非常值得進一步深思的。事實上,在解決了執政合法性的論證之後,如果能再進一步,所謂的國家治理,實際上是一種complicity,或許未嘗不是一個大膽但有趣的推論。
both the objects and the subjects, both recipients and providers of the state subsidies.
Convergence的内部是否存在更有意思的纠结与博弈?居民的主体性应该如何被理解?整体来说,细节丰富,富有洞见,关于“话语”与对象的讨论是我觉得最有意思的部分,写得太精彩了。四星~
搞成对比强烈的case可能反而会无聊,更不用说已经有像chingkwan lee在先。所以虽然两个例子连接感差一些,但中心argument还是蛮清晰的。觉得chapter5 conclusion的几个段落基本上总结了所有论点。对我自己来说的empirical note,可能还是中产没在challenge而是在reinforce/reproduce state legitimacy这回事吧。多年也没在国内呆,真的对中产的崛起一点也不清楚。
读了Intro和第五章。本来只是为了一些有用的材料才读的,结果读着读着感觉还挺有意思...作者想解决的问题,挺敏感的,野心也挺大的。不想再被封号,这块就不说了。作者对于‘素质’话语的论述对我而言是有趣的,这类看似庸常的话语在塑造一个‘先进’而驯顺,有助于和谐和稳定的,并且热衷于消费的中产阶级形象,继而巩固统治的合法性方面,发挥了无法忽视的作用。由此产生的身份区隔是这套话语体系的副产品。为了最大限度地利用这帮城市新贵的力量,另一些人就必须被打上‘无法自行管理’的低素质标签,并被视为潜在的威胁而受到额外关照。素质似乎可以后天提高,但此类区分只会被强化。越强调高低素质迥然不同,隔离就越合理;越隔离,两部分人口之间的区分便会越显著。想到之前接触的社工和社区工作人员那样自然地谈论居民素质,就感觉…哎。
我以为重点是研究基层治理,结果一大半在讲身份意识和精神怎能建设,写得很散,貌似也没啥太大意思……
用社会空间分异研究基层政治。处在地理学人类学和政治学中间地带的作品。