书籍 Dialect and Nationalism in China, 1860-1960的封面

Dialect and Nationalism in China, 1860-1960

Gina Anne Tam

出版时间

2020-04-29

ISBN

9781108478281

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

Taking aim at the conventional narrative that standard, national languages transform "peasants" into citizens, Gina Anne Tam centers the history of the Chinese nation and national identity on fangyan - languages like Shanghainese, Cantonese, and dozens of others that are categorically different from the Chinese national language, Mandarin. She traces how, on the one hand, linguists, policy-makers, bureaucrats and workaday educators framed fangyan as non-standard "variants" of the Chinese language, subsidiary in symbolic importance to standard Mandarin. She simultaneously highlights, on the other hand, the folksong collectors, playwrights, hip-hop artists and popular protestors who argued that fangyan were more authentic and representative of China's national culture and its history. From the late Qing through the height of the Maoist period, these intertwined visions of the Chinese nation - one spoken in one voice, one spoken in many - interacted and shaped one another, and in the process, shaped the basis for national identity itself.

Gina Anne Tam is Assistant Professor of Modern Chinese History at Trinity University, San Antonio.

目录
Introduction
1. A Chinese language: Fangyan before the twentieth century
2. Unchangeable roots: Fangyan and the creation of the Chinese national language
3. The sounds of authenticity: defining linguistic modernity in Republican China
4. The people's language: Fangyan under the CCP

显示全部
用户评论
讲民谣运动作为方言本真性诞生的契机那里有启发,整体一般
略粗糙,但关注点很有警示意义:方言/语音也是20世纪中国戏剧、诗歌等表演或更广泛的文化研究中不可忽视的物质性层面之一,这让我这种很少看语言研究的文盲吓出冷汗。虽然在模糊书面和口语的情况下跨层次谈方言属于巨大失误了。
不懂汉语语言学是硬伤
3.5. 更侧重于认识论与政策的讨论,作者强调自己关注民族主义如何奠定语言讨论(尤其是标准化国族语言)的基调,而非反过来讨论标准语如何创造民族国家。比较有趣的细节是pro方言论者如何继续受民族主义影响,以及GLF以前普通话与方言之间更为松动的关系。
本书将方言视作不同力量(粗略可以分为两种,一种将方言视作国语的附属,是国族建构的障碍;一种认为它指涉了本真的国家过往,能代表民族文化和历史的“本真性”)的辩证互动场所,不将国族建构与语言的关系解读为走向统一化的平滑过程,反过来看方言如何反映了多种话语力量对前面这一事业的界定及相关争论。整体的线索写来写去似乎只是语言与认同密不可分,没有看到更好的组织全书的框架。看完简介和读完全书获得的信息没有什么差别。有些地方有趣,大部分地方的展开很好预测,尤其是说方言是对说国语的一种抵抗。