书籍 Poor Economics的封面

Poor Economics

Abhijit Banerjee

出版社

PublicAffairs

出版时间

2011-04-25

ISBN

9781586487980

评分

★★★★★

标签

经济

书籍介绍

Winner of the 2011 Financial Times/Goldman Sachs Best Business Book of the Year Award

Billions of government dollars, and thousands of charitable organizations and NGOs, are dedicated to helping the world's poor. But much of their work is based on assumptions that are untested generalizations at best, harmful misperceptions at worst.

Abhijit Banerjee and Esther Duflo have pioneered the use of randomized control trials in development economics. Work based on these principles, supervised by the Poverty Action Lab, is being carried out in dozens of countries. Drawing on this and their 15 years of research from Chile to India, Kenya to Indonesia, they have identified wholly new aspects of the behavior of poor people, their needs, and the way that aid or financial investment can affect their lives. Their work defies certain presumptions: that microfinance is a cure-all, that schooling equals learning, that poverty at the level of 99 cents a day is just a more extreme version of the experience any of us have when our income falls uncomfortably low.

This important book illuminates how the poor live, and offers all of us an opportunity to think of a world beyond poverty.

Learn more at www.pooreconomics.com

目录
Foreword vii
1 Think Again, Again 1
Part I Private Lives
2 A Billion Hungry People? 19
3 Low-Hanging Fruit for Better (Global) Health? 41

显示全部
用户评论
最大的遗憾是作者没有仔细研究中国扶贫。不过依旧有很多有意义的理论。1. 穷人与普通人一样,有惰性、爱享受,所以tackle贫困问题是要充分考虑人性。2. 授人以渔:教育、稳定工作、贷款、保险等。送鱼是没有用的,直接给钱会被花在别的地方,给东西人家未必用。3. 许多政策都是过于理想主义。做什么事情需要站在穷人角度理解他们的想法。比如,穷人为啥不把钱花在可能可以提高生产率的东西上。
其实呢,飞机上没有小电视,也是有好处的…
Time inconsistency
本书的最大贡献在于帮助我们了解穷人的心理,为政策的失败提供了本土化的心理路径解释。两位实验经济学家今年喜提诺奖,让人为这一方法感到振奋。但是这可能导致发展心理学领域非实验文章不能发表,客观上增加了经费支出,也夸大了这一方法实际适用的问题范畴。实际上,RCT方法只能解释某一有限群体的决策,重复性也不高,更难说应用到国家层面的决策。本书对于贫穷对于疾病、教育等等方面的影响都有故事样的论述,既显示出这个议题的复杂,也难免让人疑惑:经济学真的抓住了表面数据和结论之下的重点吗?
a very intriguing and insightful read that challenges the common narrative of the poor and how policies/politics work in the developing country. It's the lazy and formulaic thinking that stops us nurturing tangible progress and making a difference, as gradual and slow as they may be
有声书大概听了三遍,除了每次介绍poor people的心态我都很有共鸣之外,记忆就像被洗过一样什么都没有留下。好书,就是不进我脑子
对两位经济学家表示肃然起敬
It’s amusing in an absurd way, as to watch a person waiting, devastatingly, for somebody dearly at a quay but facing the wrong direction.
我直接读了结论部分,对比了一下发现中文版的翻译从第一句开始就完全不对...虽然翻译有锅,但本文的很多论述都不大精炼,从结语部分大概就能看出很弱的逻辑组织能力,仅代表我个人观点...
很踏实的书,有观点的同时又是很好的literature review;btw,中英文版评论区反差很大,抛开翻译的质量,是不是也反映了某种区隔呢