书籍 Gang Leader for a Day的封面

Gang Leader for a Day

Sudhir Venkatesh

出版社

Penguin Press

出版时间

2008-01-10

ISBN

9781594201509

评分

★★★★★
书籍介绍

First introduced in Freakonomics , here is the full story of Sudhir Venkatesh, the sociology grad student who infiltrated one of Chicago's most notorious gangs

The story of the young sociologist who studied a Chicago crack-dealing gang from the inside captured the world's attention when it was first described in Freakonomics . Gang Leader for a Day is the fascinating full story of how Sudhir Venkatesh managed to gain entrŽe into the gang, what he learned, and how his method revolutionized the academic establishment.

When Venkatesh walked into an abandoned building in one of Chicago's most notorious housing projects, he was looking for people to take a multiple-choice survey on urban poverty. A first-year grad student hoping to impress his professors with his boldness, he never imagined that as a result of the assignment he would befriend a gang leader named JT and spend the better part of a decade inside the projects under JT's protection, documenting what he saw there.

Over the next seven years, Venkatesh got to know the neighborhood dealers, crackheads, squatters, prostitutes, pimps, activists, cops, organizers, and officials. From his privileged position of unprecedented access, he observed JT and the rest of the gang as they operated their crack-selling business, conducted PR within their community, and rose up or fell within the ranks of the gang's complex organizational structure.

In Hollywood-speak, Gang Leader for a Day is The Wire meets Harvard University. It's a brazen, page turning, and fundamentally honest view into the morally ambiguous, highly intricate, often corrupt struggle to survive in what is tantamount to an urban war zone. It is also the story of a complicated friendship between Sudhir and JT-two young and ambitious men a universe apart.

用户评论
"A drug economy, he told me, was ‘useful for the community,’since it redistributed the drug addicts’ money back into the community via the gang’s philanthropy."一笑。在《火线》里就感觉贩毒也只是(百无聊赖的)生活方式之一罢了。
读完最大的感触是在黑帮介入管理的社区的系统里,每个人的各司其职与见缝插针显得如此精巧。作者的感情太充沛了,废话很多。英文很简单,权当练阅读。
昨晚终于把最后两章翻完了。这是一个最初拿着Likert量表问卷去问黑老大你幸福吗的社会学博士生,最终走上田野调查不归路的故事。喜闻乐见。
可惜的是兄台是个Sociology的学生 换成我大Anthro的必须比这还深刻精彩
身為香港人這些故事應該耳熟能詳
英文版又读了一遍,从原来的文本中其实更能感受到当一整套与我们熟知的道德规则呈现在面前时的震撼。我们时常混淆知识与经验的范畴。知识无法代替经验,而仅凭经验也无法成为知识。当作者将社区中的道德准则,与共识中的道德准则之间的冲突展现在读者面前,或是经验材料中时,是否将这一问题悬置影响着研究的进行。当我们面对结构性的不义和不公正时,这种无力感简直一模一样。我能够从这本书里得到更多的体会,而不仅仅是贫困、地下经济和道德标准的冲突。正如中国部分人正在经历的生活一样,他们遭遇着结构性的不公,但“聪明的人”会选择耸耸肩、接受命运,逆来顺受地活下去,并进一步地在本来不利于自身地社会结构中,通过一些取巧,来为自己牟利。
跟在芝加哥黑帮大佬屁股后面做研究的流水账。作者真的naive,大家好像在babysitting「你不能去这里不能去那里不然我没法保护你!」不过看到最后一章J.T.「He's with me」那几句话还是有被感动:(
有点散乱,更像是流水账记录,但是仍然是精彩的。(spy)fly on the wall的观察记录 挺有意思的 最开始是freakanomics里面讲到他
我是第一次读这种探访黑帮背后的“田野笔记”,若不把它视为严谨的学术研究,故事本身还是精彩的。我也可以理解goodreads上的一些差评,作者确实“傻白甜”的过分了(哪有不打人的黑帮大佬),难怪大家会对他的专业性提出质疑。
好吧,新鲜感过后,感觉在读写的一般的小说了。不知道这样做qualitative research是否valid